Is MAGA dead? And was it ever really anything more than Donald Trump himself? In the wake of Republicans’ disastrous midterm performance, Ben Shapiro joined me to discuss what went wrong for the GOP and what the results reveal about the future of both parties. Shapiro believes the midterms were more a rejection of the chaos, corruption, and dysfunction of this administration than an embrace of progressive politics. I asked what Democrats should make of moderate candidates’ outperformance of their progressive counterparts—and whether the party will interpret its victory as a mandate to move further left. Shapiro thinks what Americans really want is something neither party seems willing to offer: a return to normal. We also revisit the war in Iran. Was Trump’s decision to prolong it a mistake? And to what extent did the conflict cost Republicans the election, as J.D. Vance has since argued? Shapiro says the war’s success or failure is an open question, but Trump’s decision to pause it was definitively wrong. And he rejects Vance’s attempt to blame the war for Republicans’ electoral losses. The vice president appears to be positioning himself for a 2028 presidential run by appealing to a narrower segment of the MAGA base, but Shapiro explains Trump’s coalition was uniquely his own, and Vance’s angling to inherit it, rather than build a new one, won’t pay off. We also talked about Shapiro’s surprising and remarkably successful turn as a screenwriter. His new film, Confession, stars Rob Lowe and James Franco, and is set in Joseph Stalin's Soviet Union. We then got into our all-time favorite movies, Christopher Nolan’s The Odyssey, and modern Hollywood’s apparent preference for morally ambiguous protagonists. Shapiro feels the great films of the past understood something the industry has largely forgotten—that moral clarity need not come at the expense of complexity, and that there is something profoundly compelling about watching ordinary people choose to do the right thing.