Monthly episodes discussing this topic, 2022-09 to 2026-02.
Positions people took on this topic in transcripts, grouped by school of thought. Within a camp, people with demonstrated expertise on the topic come first, then those who reached the most listeners on it. Every quote links to the episode it came from.
The potential for a team to win the Super Bowl or playoffs is currently dictated by their organizational success and roster capabilities.
6 people · 5 episodes
The New England Patriots have the potential to make a playoff run despite losing to the Buffalo Bills because the team is capable of better performance and they remain in contention.
“If they can get healthy and if they can close the right way to the season rather, I do think there's a chance they can go on a run.”
The Pat McAfee Show · Dec 2025 · 12 episodes · 4.8M views on this topicChris Brockman argues that the New England Patriots remain serious contenders in the AFC.
“The Patriots aren't going away as serious AFC contenders.”
The Rich Eisen Show · Oct 2025 · 6 episodes · 1.1M views on this topicThe Buffalo Bills are not a credible championship contender because their front office failed to provide Josh Allen with adequate offensive support.
“It can't be that obvious to us that you can't stop the run. You can't run the ball if James Cook is hurt and then all of a sudden it's just Daltton Concaid is all that can they can beat you with.”
LeBatardShow · Nov 2025 · 5 episodes · 91K views on this topicThe Green Bay Packers are still a playoff-caliber team despite recent injuries, but they are no longer a Super Bowl-contending team.
“Do I think they can make a deep run in the playoffs and win a Super Bowl? Like, no. I don't necessarily believe that. That is still on the table. They could still do it, but Micah Parsons is the best player on their team and one of the best players in the NFL.”
The Pat McAfee Show · Dec 2025 · 8 episodes · 3.5M views on this topicThe Buffalo Bills are in more trouble than the Philadelphia Eagles because their defense is struggling with a 4-2-5 scheme and their offense lacks scary wideouts.
“I think I think the Bills they've got to get out of this 4-2-5. I mean, they're giving up the most explosive plays third most explosive plays in the league 5.8 per rush. Damn. Uh you can't win that way.”
The Pat McAfee Show · Oct 2025 · 2 episodes · 559K views on this topicThe value or quality of an NFL team is primarily determined by the current performance or capability of its starting quarterback.
5 people · 4 episodes
Aaron Rodgers has performed poorly and lacks the leadership qualities necessary for an NFL quarterback.
“We've seen below-level play. And I think at some point, you know, people are going to point to the stats, right? At the end of the season, he may finish with close to 30 tubs. He may finish at eight to 10 interception, and they're going to say, "Okay, this is play you can win with."”
Stephen A. Smith · Dec 2024 · 15 episodes · 5.2M views on this topicDrake Maye is the most valuable player in the NFL this season.
“I just think Drake May is the most valuable player in the NFL and especially for his team.”
Bussin' With The Boys · Jan 2026 · 12 episodes · 325K views on this topicMatthew Stafford is the most valuable player in the NFL this season due to his superior statistics.
“I think his stats have gone above and beyond where you now need to look at it be like okay yeah Stafford's the guy now”
Bussin' With The Boys · Jan 2026 · 12 episodes · 970K views on this topicThe Minnesota Vikings have a good team but their success hinges on quarterback Sam Darnold's performance against high-level opponents.
“So yes the Vikings can be there but Sam Darnell will have something to say about that positive AR”
Stephen A. Smith · Nov 2024 · 4 episodes · 192K views on this topicAaron Rodgers is exhibiting signs of being an aging quarterback who is actively trying to avoid physical contact.
“The guy hates getting hit and he's extra pissy this year. I don't like him.”
LeBatardShow · Nov 2025 · 1 episode · 30K views on this topicPositions are extracted from transcripts by a model and may misattribute who said what. Every quote links to the episode it came from.
Includes episodes tagged with a narrower subject — each is marked with the subject it came in through.
Showing 10 of 30