Not enough disagreement in the transcripts to form camps. These are the positions taken by people with demonstrated expertise on this topic first, then by how many people heard them on it, then by VoiceRank.

Josh MileHigherhostUnrated

The most likely explanation for the disappearance of the Roanoke colonists is that they were killed.

“I don't know what I think, honestly. It's cuz like obviously the most likely scenario, they were you know, murdered.”

Mile Higher · May 2026 · 1 episode · 72K views on this topic

Positions are extracted from transcripts by a model and may misattribute who said what. Every quote links to the episode it came from.