Monthly episodes discussing this topic, 2019-08 to 2026-04.
Positions people took on this topic in transcripts, grouped by school of thought. Within a camp, people with demonstrated expertise on the topic come first, then those who reached the most listeners on it. Every quote links to the episode it came from.
The current materialist focus is a restrictive or incomplete way to understand the true nature of the mind and reality.
5 people · 5 episodes
The mind-body problem is essentially a philosophical problem that requires an expansive conception of science rather than just materialist hard science.
“I would argue that actually what we have at root here is is a philosophical rather than a purely scientific problem and I think until we confront that the philosophical underpinnings of the problem we're not really going to make progress towards a solution”
Rich Roll · Mar 2023 · 1 episode · 25K views on this topicThe current reductive materialist ideology is an optional, restrictive vision of the world that is not compelled by science or reason.
“this reductive materialist ideology which is absolutely not uh compelled on us as people seem to think by science or by reason”
Jordan B Peterson · Aug 2022 · 3 episodes · 1.7M views on this topicThe mind is not a product of the physical brain alone but is an pattern from an abstract Platonic space that manifests through a physical interface.
“Nobody's creating consciousness. What you create is a physical interface through which specific patterns, which we call kinds of minds, are going to ingress, right? And consciousness is what it looks like from that direction looking out into the world.”
Lex Fridman Podcast · Nov 2025 · 1 episode · 957K views on this topicConsciousness should be viewed as a fundamental property that exists at the foundation of reality rather than as something that emerges from physical processes.
“My view is that you should put consciousness at the bottom. That consciousness has to be there from the beginning. You need some rudimentary consciousness for evolution by natural selection to play with.”
Jordan B Peterson · Sep 2024 · 1 episode · 164K views on this topicHuman consciousness includes a mysterious dimension that cannot be reduced solely to biological or material survival.
“I'm nervous about reducing something simply to survival and kind of put it into the kind of physiological biological realm. I think that we need to look at elements of nature that are beyond our comprehension because on some level if we back out far survival is really important but we don't know wha”
Rich Roll · Sep 2025 · 1 episode · 37K views on this topicConsciousness and intelligence are fundamentally tied to biological existence, bodily interaction, or environmental integration.
4 people · 4 episodes
The belief that consciousness is merely a computational algorithm or software that can be uploaded into silicon is a flawed metaphor that ignores the biological reality of the brain.
“the premise of conscious AI is that consciousness is an algorithm or a software that you can run on any number of different kinds of material substrates they call it. So I think that that's a it just doesn't work. It's it's not brains are nothing like computers.”
Armchair Expert with Dax Shepard · Apr 2026 · 4 episodes · 1.4M views on this topicHuman knowledge is intrinsically limited by our nature as finite beings, and it is a mistake to believe we can achieve a god's-eye view of reality by transcending embodiment.
“And my point is that we're not those kinds of beings. We only acquire knowledge through this arduous process of interaction which means that we cannot claim to have that god's eye neutral view on things but that it would be it's a mistake about knowledge and about ourselves as knowers to think that ”
Machine Learning Street Talk · Jan 2026 · 1 episode · 19K views on this topicA computer simulation of a brain is not an agent unless it is physically embodied in a body and interacting with the world.
“So, yeah, let's say highfidelity computer simulation of Jeff. Would would would Jeff be an agent? >> No. Oh, wasn't expecting you to say that >> because I'm the agent and if you uh uploaded No, I don't know. Um, so if you is do a highfidelity computer simulation and you put it in my body, then I thi”
Machine Learning Street Talk · Jan 2026 · 1 episode · 12K views on this topicThe mind is not limited to the brain inside the skull but extends into the body, physical surroundings, and social relationships.
“Clark and Chalmers were arguing that no, actually the mind extends beyond the skull into the movements and sensations of our bodies, into, uh, our physical surroundings where we think and learn and work into our relationships with other people and into our tools and devices.”
10% Happier · Oct 2025 · 1 episode · 3K views on this topicPositions are extracted from transcripts by a model and may misattribute who said what. Every quote links to the episode it came from.
Includes episodes tagged with a narrower subject — each is marked with the subject it came in through.
Showing 10 of 30