Cenk Uygur argues that Tucker Carlson's critique of Israeli government policy is legitimate and that establishment figures are unfairly conflating this criticism with anti-Semitism to silence him.

“So, are we supposed to help them eliminate the people on the right like Tucker Carlson and Candace Owens who are actually waking people up on the right about what Israel is doing to not just the Palestinians but to our government?”

Ana Kasparian believes that Tucker Carlson has consistently pushed anti-Semitic conspiracy theories throughout his media career, and she considers his platforming of Nick Fuentes to be a dangerous pat

“I think what's dangerous here, because Tucker let in not just this interview, but many interviews on his show and then also on his show on Fox, he has explicitly himself pushed anti-semitic conspiracy theories”