Jeremy Rys believes Bob Lazar's story is false and points to inconsistencies, lack of evidence, and his history of fabrication.

“well the the biggest holes I would say there's a couple of them um so one is this that issue of how he was hired in the first place the background the background check is the biggest hole”

Mark Gagnon believes that Bob Lazar is likely an unwitting source of misinformation used by intelligence agencies rather than a liar or a government agent himself.

“I think the Bennewitz thing is the most compelling feeling for me. That the government, for some reason, is setting this guy up with information so that he goes around this whole media circus telling the story that he is not lying about but isn't fully true.”