Lindsay Clancy — a labor & delivery nurse with no history of violence — strangled her three children on January 24, 2023, then jumped from a second-story window. She survived, paralyzed. Now she faces murder charges, and her defense will rest on one question: was she legally insane? Tonight, Bob and Ali break down the newly filed civil malpractice suit by attorney Rosemary Scapicchio — a 29-page roadmap to the insanity defense. The complaint alleges eight medical defendants missed bipolar disorder with postpartum onset, prescribed a dozen medications in four months, ignored two textbook red-flag reactions to antidepressants, and discharged her from the nation's top psychiatric hospital after just five days — with documented "limited" insight and active suicidal ideation. She went to ERs. She called crisis hotlines. She admitted herself to hospitals. She told them the meds were making her worse. And the voices told her she had no other way out. Can a jury set aside the unthinkable and follow the evidence? We're covering this case gavel to gavel — starting tonight with the case primer. Just facts. Balls and strikes. #LindsayClancy #TrueCrime #DefenseDiaries 00:00:00 - Intro, Greetings & Summary of the Lindsay Clancy Case 00:03:00 - Trigger Warning: Initial Thoughts + TODAY: Criminal Affidavit, Civil Lawsuit & Hearing 07/13/26 00:21:00 - Getting Closer to the Goal! 300 Away From 70K - Please Subscribe! 00:22:20 - Reading the Probable Cause Affidavit + Case Analysis & Commentary 00:37:00 - Conclusions on the Affidavit & Final Takeaways 00:44:00 - Reviewing Jury Instructions: The "Lack of Criminal Responsibility" Defense 00:47:40 - Beyond a Reasonable Doubt: How the State Must Prove Criminal Responsibility 00:54:00 - Supplemental Instructions: Intoxication vs. Lack of Criminal Responsibility 00:56:00 - Legal Consequences of a "Not Guilty by Reason of Insanity" (NGI) Verdict 00:59:00 - Civil Action Phase: Norfolk Superior Court First Amended Complaint & Jury Demand 01:02:45 - The Parties Involved in the Litigation 01:06:45 - Jurisdiction & Venue. FACTS: A.Lindsay Clancy and Her Family 01:08:30 - B. Breaking Down Lindsay's Prior Postpartum Medical History 01:10:25 - C. The Third Pregnancy and the Initial Postpartum Period 01:11:40 - D. Lindsay's Desperate Attempts to Seek Medical Help 01:22:30 - E. Women & Infants Hospitals' Failure to Properly Treat Lindsay 01:27:50 - F. McLean Hospital and Dr. Goodheart's Failure to Properly Treat Lindsay 01:33:00 - G. Continued Medical Deterioration Under Dr. Tufts' Care 01:38:10 - I. Expert Psychiatric Opinions 01:42:00 - J. Defendant's Violations on the Standard of Care 01:46:00 - Count I: Negligence, Medical Malpractice & Personal Injury Claims 01:48:00 - Quick Legal Breakdown of the Counts 01:48:10 - Counts II, III & IV: Loss of Parental Consortium, Spousal Consortium & Vicarious Liability 01:49:00 - The Demand for a Jury Trial: Re-Reviewing Crucial Paragraphs of the Suit 01:52:45 - H. January 24, 2023 01:55:20 - Legal Analysis, Super Chats, Conversation and comments 02:03:00 - Replay Court Stream: The July 13th Pre-Trial Hearing - The Judge Listens to Arguments 02:07:00 - Perspectives & Deep Discussions on Public Mental Health Care 02:09:00 - Heading Back to the Pre-Trial Hearing Stream & Commentary 02:14:30 - The Judge's Response. Super Chats, comments & questions 02:29:40 - Answering comments from the Chat: "would you do a bench trial here?" & "The Children Need Justice Also" 02:37:00 - Looking Ahead: Defense Diaries Schedule for Next Week 02:39:30 - Seeking Justice Discord Shout-Out! DISCORD LINK: https://discord.gg/6q2YysJnAw (join to learn about cases, court documents, information and also fun & watch parties!) 02:43:00 - Singing the Birthday Song for Tracy! Together on the Big Screen 02:44:00 - Final Thanks & Goodbyes! Thank you Fam for joining us today on this hard and tough case. DD will be covering trial & for this one we need lots of Fam hugs! We love you