Monthly episodes discussing this topic, 2025-05 to 2026-01.
Positions people took on this topic in transcripts, grouped by school of thought. Within a camp, people with demonstrated expertise on the topic come first, then those who reached the most listeners on it. Every quote links to the episode it came from.
ICE operations function as an unconstitutional or performative paramilitary force that targets innocent people and causes unnecessary…
29 people · 24 episodes
The current immigration enforcement efforts in Los Angeles are needlessly provocative.
“I don't think anyone would be complaining about a rational system of due process getting rid of criminals. But this right now is needlessly provocative in Los Angeles.”
The Daily Show · Jun 2025 · 1 episode · 2.2M views on this topicTrump's immigration policy has resulted in a massive, negative backlash due to his overreactions.
“Trump's terrible policy has generated a huge backlash, which he's responded to by overreacting, which is going to generate another backlash.”
The Daily Show · Jun 2025 · 1 episode · 2.2M views on this topicThe Department of Homeland Security’s use of tear gas near children during trick-or-treating is cruel and reflects a total lack of empathy for communities.
“Can we agree that there is no imminent threat that should disrupt their holiday? No child in America should have to go trick-or-treating in fear that they might be confronted with armed federal agents and have to inhale tear gas. I ask you to restore some sanity for the sake of our children.”
Pod Save America · Oct 2025 · 5 episodes · 1.1M views on this topicThe surge of ICE and Border Patrol agents in cities is a paramilitary invasion that functions as a tool of authoritarian control rather than legitimate law enforcement.
“These paramilitary forces that are being used against the American people, against United States citizens. I am horrified right now at what I'm seeing.”
MeidasTouch · Jan 2026 · 2 episodes · 956K views on this topicICE is operating as an illegal secret police force, which functions as a pretense to build a fascist state.
“I think this is about putting an illegal secret police force, masked police, and I I don't even want to call them police. They're just these these thugs, these paramilitary forces, these enforcers of the Trump regime putting these masked secret forces on the streets in order to terrorize the populat”
MeidasTouch · Jan 2026 · 2 episodes · 956K views on this topicICE operations are legitimate law enforcement efforts necessary for public safety and carrying out the democratic will of the voters.
13 people · 10 episodes
ICE operations prioritize apprehending public safety and national security threats, with a high percentage of arrests involving individuals with criminal histories.
“I looked at the numbers yesterday. The last report I saw about 130,000 total interior enforcement arrest by ICE. 90,000 of those were criminals. Do the math. That's 70%.”
Stephen A. Smith · Jul 2025 · 2 episodes · 2.5M views on this topicThe death of Alex Pretti was an avoidable consequence of him interfering with federal law enforcement during a protest while carrying a firearm.
“I don't go to protest with other agents who have guns and interfere with official federal business. Okay? You know why? Because I'm not stupid, Patrick. And I know I know that there's a possibility if I get into a fight, something crazy might happen.”
PBD Podcast · Jan 2026 · 3 episodes · 1.4M views on this topicThe shooting of Alex Pretti was a preventable tragedy directly caused by the failure of state leadership to cooperate with federal immigration enforcement.
“I said this 100% on Tim Waltz. This [snorts] could have been prevented if you could. You lost complete control of your people. And I got a lot of people that were not happy about my comment. But I will tell you exactly why I am not changing my position and the comments I I made. Alex Pretty should b”
PBD Podcast · Jan 2026 · 2 episodes · 1.1M views on this topicTom Ellsworth believes the primary failure in Minneapolis is the leadership and local policies that have created an environment of chaos and lawlessness.
“To me this is just an ultimate failure of leadership, whether it's this mayor Jacob Frey or Tim Walz, every major incident that we've seen in this country for the most part in the last 5 years has occurred in one city, Minneapolis, Minnesota.”
PBD Podcast · Jan 2026 · 2 episodes · 1.1M views on this topicDave Rubin argues that ICE operations are generally right despite some optics issues regarding masked agents and occasional mistakes.
“So on one hand, I I kind of get what Rogan saying and I've said the same thing. There's sort of like an optics problem here because when you have these masked guys on the streets and I'm I'm all for them wearing masks because their families are getting doxed and all the rest of it, but there is a bi”
The Rubin Report · Jan 2026 · 4 episodes · 758K views on this topicThe agency suffers from critical failures in recruitment, training, and oversight that compromise its professionalism and legal integrity.
4 people · 3 episodes
The agency's recruitment and background check processes are dangerously inadequate and lack sufficient oversight.
“If Ice didn't screen her out, they also can't be expected to hire competent recruits”
Philip DeFranco · Jan 2026 · 1 episode · 813K views on this topicThe administration is recruiting for ICE positions individuals with attitudes and behaviors that are unprofessional and contrary to standard community relations training.
“the idea that somebody would say they would, you know, deport people for free and and do the aggressive actions that that guy's taking uh and they would do it for free, I think tells you a lot about the kinds of people that they're recruiting for these jobs.”
MeidasTouch · Jan 2026 · 1 episode · 99K views on this topicMaria Cardona believes that the current recruitment and training process for ICE agents is critically inadequate and has lowered the quality of new hires.
“they are handing people who want guns with little training who literally want to go out there and hunt immigrants. Michael, and as you know, I'm a Latina. I'm an immigrant. This scares the [ __ ] out of me because while I do not want to paint every single ICE agent with that broad brush, I am scared”
MeidasTouch · Jan 2026 · 1 episode · 41K views on this topicMichael Cohen views the 47-day training program for ICE agents as an irrational, arbitrary policy change motivated solely by political symbolism.
“Why 47 days? The reason why it's 47 days >> is because Donald Trump is the 47th president of the United States. And so I want people to understand just how stupid that is conceptually. If he was the if he was the fifth president of the United States, you could become an ICE agent in 5 days.”
MeidasTouch · Jan 2026 · 1 episode · 41K views on this topicPositions are extracted from transcripts by a model and may misattribute who said what. Every quote links to the episode it came from.
Includes episodes tagged with a narrower subject — each is marked with the subject it came in through.
Showing 10 of 30