Monthly episodes discussing this topic, 2017-11 to 2026-03.
Positions people took on this topic in transcripts, grouped by school of thought. Within a camp, people with demonstrated expertise on the topic come first, then those who reached the most listeners on it. Every quote links to the episode it came from.
This group argues that standard police protocols and investigative decisions are often flawed, insufficient, or inappropriate.
4 people · 4 episodes
She believes it was a massive mistake that the authorities did not perform a rape kit given that the body was found partially undressed.
“I think it was a massive mistake that they did not do a rape kid I think when you find a victim without their clothes that should just be standard I mean why why not right like why not just double check”
Mile Higher · Mar 2023 · 24 episodes · 43.1M views on this topicEleanor Neale expresses surprise at the police charging a suspect with murder without having the suspect in custody or having interviewed them.
“they charged him with murder meaning no matter what happened when they found him he was 100 percent going to face trial they didn't even need to question him interview him arrest him nothing on-site he is charged with her murder which is something i've never in all of the cases that i've covered i'v”
OUTLORE with Eleanor Neale · Mar 2021 · 1 episode · 1.9M views on this topicDawn Englebert suggests that external authorities should take over the investigation to provide a fresh perspective.
“I think we need calls to upper governments and asking for new eyes to come in”
Kendall Rae · May 2022 · 0 episodes · 0 views on this topicThe initial police response to a missing person report, requiring a 48-hour wait before filing, is an inappropriate way to handle such cases.
“Which which is I just don't think this is the way we should be handling people going missing.”
True Crime Garage TV · Feb 2026 · 0 episodes · 0 views on this topicThis group emphasizes the importance of avoiding premature speculation and maintaining skepticism toward unverified claims or evidence.
3 people · 3 episodes
There is no benefit to being the first to speculate on a case, and one should avoid making assumptions when evidence is limited.
“I think it's just there's no prize for being first when it comes to thinking up something. And in this case, again, as I mentioned, you know, we were pretty hard on them for not sharing more information. And turns out we were totally wrong about that. So, I think stuff like that, I'm not going to be”
True Crime Garage TV · Oct 2025 · 1 episode · 6K views on this topicHe maintains that the flat tires on Chelsea's abandoned vehicle were most likely caused by the rocky terrain rather than being slashed.
“I am going to have to go with that and I think it's very you know I don't see any reason why they would lie about that it seems very weird to or to withhold that kind of information”
Mile Higher · Jun 2024 · 4 episodes · 1.9M views on this topicThe homeless man's claim of seeing Brian eating a sandwich should be treated with caution because many individuals could be mistaken for a white male college student at that hour.
“There are would be a lot of persons that look like a white male in their mid20s dressed like a college student out in the middle of the night on a on a weekend. And so, while I think that this individual is trying to be helpful, I don't want anybody to walk away from this conversation going”
True Crime Garage TV · Feb 2026 · 3 episodes · 20K views on this topicPositions are extracted from transcripts by a model and may misattribute who said what. Every quote links to the episode it came from.
Includes episodes tagged with a narrower subject — each is marked with the subject it came in through.
Showing 10 of 30